Connect with us

Bridging Parenting

Bridging Parenting #8: Should We Force Children to Share? — Sharing Is a Skill That Develops Gradually

Published

on

Last week, we attended several different birthday parties. One scene kept repeating itself: a child tightly clutching onto their toy while adults took turns persuading them — “Be more generous.” “Don’t be so selfish.” “Let your little sister play with it.” Sometimes, the toy was even taken directly from the child and handed to another.

For families with only one child, sharing can already be difficult. For families with two or more children, parents often deal with conflicts over sharing every single day. Adults hope to teach politeness and generosity. But what we often see on the child’s face is anxiety and defensiveness. So the question is: should we force children to share?

Sharing Is Actually a Developmental Spectrum

From a developmental psychology perspective, sharing is not something that happens instantly. It develops gradually alongside brain maturity and emotional growth.

Ages 2–3: The Ownership Stage

At this age, children are learning the concept of “This is mine.” A sense of ownership is an important foundation of self-development. When a child clings tightly to a toy, they are often trying to establish boundaries — not intentionally being selfish.

Ages 4–6: The Rule-Learning Stage

Children begin to understand ideas like taking turns and fairness, though this understanding usually still depends on external reminders. Sharing at this stage is often prompted by adults rather than internally motivated.

Age 7 and Above: The Internalisation Stage

As empathy and moral reasoning develop, children become more capable of seeing things from another person’s perspective. Psychologist Lawrence Kohlberg suggested that moral development progresses from avoiding punishment to understanding social norms and the needs of others. Genuine generosity comes from internal values, not external pressure.

In other words, sharing does not magically appear once a child reaches a certain age. It develops gradually through cognitive maturity and emotional security.

What Happens When We Force Sharing?

When adults suddenly take a toy away, children may learn:

  • My boundaries do not matter.
  • Things can be taken away unexpectedly.
  • I need to hold on even tighter.

Attachment theory suggests that a sense of security is built when boundaries are respected. Self-Determination Theory also tells us that humans naturally need autonomy. When children feel controlled, they often resist more strongly. When they feel respected, they become more willing to cooperate.

True generosity grows from safety and autonomy — not pressure.

Step by Step: Teaching Instead of Forcing

1|Respect Ownership and Give Time

When a child clings to a toy, you might say:
“This is yours. I understand you don’t want to share right now.”

Then add:
“When you’re ready, you can choose to share it. Let me know when you feel ready.”

If the child still says no, there is no need to rush into correction. You can calmly respond:
“That’s okay. We can check again later.”

A few minutes later, ask again:
“Are you ready now?”

This process helps children practise self-regulation and delayed response, rather than immediate obedience.

2|Encourage Empathy, Not Pressure

If the child still refuses, you can gently add:
“Your little sister is waiting over there. She would really like a turn too.”

This is not criticism — it is simply information. Children begin to notice the feelings and needs of others. Empathy often develops more naturally in a safe environment than under pressure.

3|Teach Taking Turns

If letting go is still difficult, you can say:
“You can play for two more minutes, then we’ll take turns.”

Taking turns is often the foundation of sharing. Developmentally, it is much more realistic than expecting a child to immediately give something up.

What I Observed at Home

When my daughter was around two years old, she also used to cling tightly to her toys. Instead of taking them away, I often reminded her:
“This is your toy. You can decide when to share it. If you’re not ready, you can tell the other child.”

Sometimes she chose not to share. Sometimes, a few minutes later, she would hand the toy over on her own.

I realised that when she knew her belongings would not be forcibly taken away, she actually found it easier to let go.

Of course, there were still difficult moments. Sometimes she resisted. Sometimes she cried. But my goal was never to raise a “perfectly generous” child overnight. What I hope for is that, with her boundaries respected, she slowly learns how to balance holding on and letting go.

True sharing is not motivated by fear of punishment. It comes from knowing: even if I give something away, I am still safe.

Final Thoughts

Children are not born selfish. They are learning how to balance ownership and relationships. Sharing is not about being forced to give something up. It is a choice that grows gradually through safety and autonomy.

Between holding on and letting go, what we are really teaching is not obedience — but respect and trust. When boundaries are acknowledged, generosity often follows naturally.

About the Author
Chloe Wong

Chloe Wong is an immigrant mother and speech pathologist based in Melbourne. She is the founder of Blackburn Speech & Paediatric Therapy, a bilingual multidisciplinary clinic supporting children and families from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds.

Having worked closely with immigrant families for many years, Chloe believes that while grandparents and parents may differ in approach, their intention is the same — to give the next generation a better life.

Through this column, she brings together research-informed insights and practical strategies to build bridges between generations, helping love translate into meaningful, effective support for children.

Follow her on Instagram: @phd.speechie.mum

Continue Reading

Bridging Parenting

Bridging Parenting #11: “Should We Speak Cantonese/Mandarin or English?” — The Language Dilemma for Migrant Families Isn’t Really a Dilemma

Published

on

In my clinic, I often meet parents facing the same question. They grew up in Hong Kong or mainland China and speak Cantonese or Mandarin at home (which I’ll refer to as the home language). Their children are born in Australia, attend local schools, and speak English with their classmates.

Then the questions begin:

“Should I keep speaking our home language with my child, or should I switch to English so they can keep up at school?”

“Their home language isn’t very strong, and it feels like their English is developing more slowly too. Is this good for them?”

I completely understand these concerns. My own family speaks Cantonese at home. I also understand the pressure parents feel if their child isn’t speaking English fluently. This is a common experience among migrant families: you want to preserve your linguistic and cultural roots, but you’re afraid those very roots might become an obstacle as your child adapts to a new world.

But I want to reassure you—those roots are never an obstacle.

“Will Being Bilingual Confuse My Child?” — What the Research Actually Says

One of the most common concerns is that learning two languages at the same time will “confuse” children, leaving them unable to master either language well.

Fortunately, this concern is not supported by research.

Studies on children’s language development consistently show that the bilingual brain is not like a container with limited space, where adding one language pushes another out. In fact, the opposite is true.

Two languages can coexist without interfering with each other—they often strengthen one another.

Language learning is built around concepts. The concepts a child learns in their home language transfer to English, and the language intuition they develop in English can also enrich their ability to express themselves in their home language.

The only accurate statement is that bilingual children may have a slightly smaller vocabulary in each individual language during early childhood compared with monolingual children. However, when vocabulary across both languages is combined, their total vocabulary is generally comparable to—or even larger than—that of monolingual children.

Your Home Language Is One of the Greatest Gifts You Can Give Your Child

After many years working as a speech pathologist in Australia, I’ve supported numerous migrant families.

I’ve seen many parents become so worried about their child’s English that they start speaking English themselves—even though they aren’t fully comfortable with it.

Ironically, this often works against the child’s language development.

Research clearly shows that the language parents speak most naturally, richly, and emotionally is the best language for supporting their child’s development.

If you can tell stories, discuss feelings, ask thoughtful questions, and have meaningful conversations in your home language, then keep speaking it.

You’re not holding back your child’s English—you are building the foundation of their language development.

Your child will learn English at school.

But those bedtime conversations, family stories, shared laughter, and emotional connections in your home language are something school can never replace.

Step by Step: How Families Can Support Bilingual Development

Step 1: Continue Speaking Your Home Language at Home

Don’t worry that your child’s English will fall behind.

Providing a consistent home-language environment is one of the most valuable things you can do. School, friends, and the wider community will provide abundant English exposure. Your home language, however, is something only your family can provide.

Step 2: Fill the Home Language with Emotion

Language is about much more than memorising vocabulary or learning Chinese characters.

Sing songs together. Read stories. Play games. Say “I love you.”

The strength of a language lies not in how formal it is, but in the emotional connections it creates.

Step 3: Don’t Rush to Correct Every Mistake

When your child speaks your home language—even if they mix in English or make mistakes—respond first to what they’re trying to communicate.

Then gently model the correct expression.

For example, if your child says:

“I want to eat rice.”

You might reply:

“Yes, you’re hungry and you’d like to eat some rice. Let’s go and have dinner.”

Responding to the message is more important than correcting the language.

Step 4: Don’t Aim for Perfection

Language is part of everyday life—not an exam.

Code-switching, mixing English into conversations, or forgetting certain words are all perfectly normal parts of growing up bilingual.

Your goal shouldn’t be for your child to speak “perfect” Cantonese or Mandarin.

Your goal is for them to want to keep speaking your home language with you.

That is what strong roots look like.

A Final Thought

As migrant families, we often feel that language is a choice:

Should we choose our home language—or English?

In reality, they were never opposites.

Your home language is your child’s first window to the world.

English is the road that allows them to step confidently into it.

They need both.

Holding on to your language isn’t being stubborn—it’s being wise.

Because one day, when your child has grown up and can speak with their parents in the family language, read letters from home, or find comfort in familiar words while living far away, they will understand that those roots were planted by you.

About the Author
Chloe Wong

Chloe Wong is an immigrant mother and speech pathologist based in Melbourne. She is the founder of Blackburn Speech & Paediatric Therapy, a bilingual multidisciplinary clinic supporting children and families from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds.

Having worked closely with immigrant families for many years, Chloe believes that while grandparents and parents may differ in approach, their intention is the same — to give the next generation a better life.

Through this column, she brings together research-informed insights and practical strategies to build bridges between generations, helping love translate into meaningful, effective support for children.

Follow her on Instagram: @phd.speechie.mum

Continue Reading

Bridging Parenting

Bridging Parenting #10: “I Don’t Know How to Start” — Talking to Teenagers About Sex and Relationships Matters More Than You Think

Published

on

One afternoon, a mother told me she had walked into her teenager’s room to change the sheets. She found something under the pillow. She just stood there, hand still resting on it, not knowing whether to pretend she hadn’t seen anything, or to say something, or what that something would even be.

In the end, she said nothing.

Then there was a father who discovered his son had been watching pornography on his phone. He closed the screen. But he carried it around for days afterwards — should I bring it up? how do I bring it up? what do I even say? — and in the end, he too said nothing.

And then there is the scene that so many families have lived through: a child runs into the room at the wrong moment and walks in on parents being intimate. Everyone freezes. The child runs back out. The parents look at each other. And then — silence.

I have heard versions of these stories more times than I can count.

Many parents carry a quiet hope: “Surely the school will cover this.” And I understand why. This is not an easy topic to raise. But the reality is that school-based sex education is limited — it tends to cover biology, reproduction, maybe some basics about consent, and not much else. The messy, confusing, emotional parts that teenagers are actually navigating rarely get addressed in a classroom.

Sex education needs to start at home.

The trouble is, most parents are not avoiding it because they do not care. They are avoiding it because they genuinely do not know where to begin.

Recently, I sat down with my friend Dr. James Lee — occupational therapist and sex therapist — to record a new episode of Bilingual Speech Spot: From Awkward to Authentic — How Parents Can Talk About Sex and Love with Teens. This article is an extension of that conversation.

It Was Never Just About Sex

When teenagers enter puberty, their bodies change — but so does their emotional world. Curiosity about relationships, attraction, and intimacy is completely normal at this stage.

But when parents stay silent, that curiosity does not disappear. It just goes somewhere else — TikTok, peers, the corners of the internet that offer answers that are incomplete, exaggerated, or just wrong.

Dr. James reminded us in this episode that sex education was never only about the act itself. It is about understanding that love takes many forms, and physical intimacy is just one of them. Quality time together, actually listening to each other, emotional support — these are all part of what love looks like. When teenagers understand that, they go into relationships with something solid underneath them.

The Moments Parents Dread Most

Dr. James addressed two scenarios that parents find almost impossible to navigate.

When a child walks in on parents being intimate. The instinct for many is panic, then silence. But this moment can actually be handled quite simply. You do not need to explain everything. A calm, short response — “Mum and Dad were having private time together. That is part of how adults who love each other show it” — is enough. Then move on. What your child picks up on most is not your words. It is your tone. Calm and matter-of-fact tells them this is a normal part of life, not something shameful.

When you discover a teenager masturbating, or are discovered. For many Asian families, this is even harder. Dr. James’ guidance is simple: respond with calm and dignity, not shame. This is normal adolescent development. If you are the one who walked in, a quiet “I should have knocked — I’m sorry” followed by giving them space is the right response. Later, when things feel settled, a calm conversation about private space and personal boundaries can follow naturally. Shame does not teach teenagers about limits. It teaches them to hide.

Step-by-Step: How to Start These Conversations Without Making It Weird

Step 1|Don’t schedule a talk — let it happen sideways

Nothing closes a teenager down faster than a parent saying, “We need to have an important conversation.” The moment those words come out, the walls go up.

The conversations that actually land tend to happen when you are both doing something else entirely.

For example, you are watching a series together and a character is dealing with a relationship mess. You just say, “Do you think he handled that well? What would you have done?” You have not asked about your child’s life directly. But the door is open.

Or on the drive home from training, you could say, “A mum asked me something the other day about teenagers and dating and I wasn’t sure what to think — what’s your take?” Using someone else’s story, even a vague one, feels much safer to a teenager than feeling like they are being questioned about themselves.

Sideways conversations go further than direct ones almost every time.

Step 2|Start from their world, not yours

Asking a teenager “what do you think about relationships?” out of nowhere will get you a shrug. But starting from something they already care about is a completely different experience.

If their favourite artist just went through a public breakup, you could say, “Did you see what happened with them? What did you make of it?” Then just follow the conversation wherever it goes — towards respect, towards how people treat each other, towards what actually makes a relationship feel good or bad.

Or if they mention a friend who has started dating someone, a relaxed “are they good together? what do you think makes two people actually work?” is enough to open things up. No interrogation. Just genuine interest. You listen, mostly. That is it.

Step 3|Information, not warnings

“If you do this, that will happen” tends to produce eye-rolls, not reflection.

Try a different approach instead.

For example, you could say: “Different people make different choices about this — some wait until they feel really sure about someone, others think differently. But the one thing that matters no matter what is that both people genuinely want to be there, and both feel safe. That is what makes it okay.” You are not giving permission. You are giving them a framework for thinking — something they can actually use when you are not in the room.

Or if you know your child has come across pornography, you could say simply, “You know that stuff online doesn’t really look like what real relationships are like, right? Real intimacy is when both people feel safe and respected.” Just one quiet sentence. You do not need a lecture. Teenagers take in more than they let on.

Your goal is not to frighten them into good choices. It is to help them become someone who can tell the difference.

Step 4|Make it clear they can always come back to you

This one sounds simple, but it is built slowly, over many small moments.

Whether your teenager comes back to you depends entirely on what happened the last time they tried.

For example, if your child mentions casually, “My friend told me he likes someone,” and your immediate response is “Who? When did this happen? Why didn’t you tell me?” — they will not mention it next time. But if you just say, “Oh, did he say anything to her yet?” and let them lead, what they feel is: it is safe to tell you things.

Or imagine your teenager asks you something unexpected one day — “Mum, what’s contraception?” Many parents instinctively panic and respond with “Why are you asking that?” But that question tells your child immediately: this is not something I can bring to you.

Try taking a breath first, then saying: “Good question. Where did you come across that?” Find out the context before jumping to the answer. What your child experiences is a parent who does not flinch. And that feeling — that you will not change towards them just because they asked something sensitive — is exactly what makes them come back the next time they are confused or worried.

That is the door worth keeping open.

In Closing

Many Asian parents are not really afraid their child will “go wrong.” They are afraid of saying the wrong thing, or of opening something they do not know how to handle.

But maybe the best protection we can give our teenagers is just being the person they feel they can actually come back to.

Awkwardness gets easier with practice. But that door has to be opened by us first.

If you would like to listen to this episode, search for Bilingual Speech Spot on your podcast platform, or visit drbilingual.com/podcast.

About the Author
Chloe Wong

Chloe Wong is an immigrant mother and speech pathologist based in Melbourne. She is the founder of Blackburn Speech & Paediatric Therapy, a bilingual multidisciplinary clinic supporting children and families from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds.

Having worked closely with immigrant families for many years, Chloe believes that while grandparents and parents may differ in approach, their intention is the same — to give the next generation a better life.

Through this column, she brings together research-informed insights and practical strategies to build bridges between generations, helping love translate into meaningful, effective support for children.

Follow her on Instagram: @phd.speechie.mum



Continue Reading

Bridging Parenting

Bridging Parenting #9: How to Start Sex Education With Children

Published

on

Sex education is about safety, boundaries, and respect

Recently, I invited my good friend, occupational therapist and sex therapist Dr. James Lee, to record a podcast episode on sex education. While researching and preparing the content, I realised many parents have strong taboos around the topic.

“Когда should we start talking about it?”
“Will it be too early?”
“What if my child suddenly asks something—how should I answer?”

In many Asian families, “sex” is often a difficult subject to talk about. Many people in the older generation did not receive this kind of education, and concepts such as boundaries, consent, or bodily autonomy were rarely discussed. As a result, many parents tend to hope they can delay it—wait until the child is older, wait for schools to teach it, or wait until the child “figures it out”.

But sex education is not only about sexual behaviour. It is about how children understand their own bodies, how they protect themselves, how they respect others’ boundaries, and whether they know they can say “no” when they feel uncomfortable. These things actually start much earlier than most people think.

Sex education should begin when children are very young

Many parents think sex education only begins in adolescence. But from a developmental psychology perspective, children start forming ideas about bodily boundaries, safety, autonomy, and physical contact in early childhood.

For example:

  • When a child says “I don’t want a hug,” do adults respect it?
  • When bathing a child, do we teach which parts are private parts?
  • When relatives ask for hugs or kisses, does the child have the right to say “no”?

These are already part of sex education.

Why does sex education feel “awkward”?

Many parents do not lack concern—they lack confidence in how to start, because they were never taught themselves. In their upbringing, bodies were often not openly discussed, and obedience was emphasised.

So when we talk about “boundaries,” “consent,” and “bodily autonomy,” parents are also learning.

The question is: would you rather your child learn about sex from you, or from TikTok, peers, or exaggerated online content?

Helping children understand their feelings is key protection

Safety education is important—“don’t go with strangers,” “scream if someone touches you.” But research shows children are best protected when they are taught to trust their feelings from an early age.

If a child is always taught to tolerate discomfort, always obey physical affection, and never refuse, they may struggle later to recognise boundary violations.

Sex education is not only about danger—it is about teaching:
“Your feelings matter. If you feel uncomfortable, you can say so.”

Step-by-step: how to start naturally

Step 1: Use correct names for body parts

Teach children proper terms like penis, vagina, chest, bottom. This builds body awareness and protection ability. Treat private parts like other body parts—there is nothing shameful about them.

Step 2: Respect a child’s “no”

If a child refuses hugs or kisses, respond with alternatives like a wave or high-five. This teaches that boundaries are allowed and relationships are still safe.

Step 3: Build consent into daily life

Ask permission in everyday situations:

  • “Can I wipe your face?”
  • “Do you want mummy to help or do it yourself?”

Also encourage children to ask consent from others.

Step 4: Make sure children can always come back to you

Children need to know they can talk to you without fear of blame or punishment. Safety at home matters more than silence or secrecy.

Final thoughts

Many Asian families avoid sex education because they believe silence equals protection. But silence does not prevent exposure—it only prevents guidance.

Sex education is not just about sex. It is about safety, boundaries, respect, autonomy, and emotional security.

When children know their feelings are valid, their bodies are respected, and they can say “no”, they grow up with a stronger sense of safety and trust.

About the Author
Chloe Wong

Chloe Wong is an immigrant mother and speech pathologist based in Melbourne. She is the founder of Blackburn Speech & Paediatric Therapy, a bilingual multidisciplinary clinic supporting children and families from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds.

Having worked closely with immigrant families for many years, Chloe believes that while grandparents and parents may differ in approach, their intention is the same — to give the next generation a better life.

Through this column, she brings together research-informed insights and practical strategies to build bridges between generations, helping love translate into meaningful, effective support for children.

Follow her on Instagram: @phd.speechie.mum

Continue Reading

Trending